Blogs | Sports | News
Bucco Blog

I don’t believe what I just heard (and why that’s OK) … And a rule Major League Baseball should adopt


DETROIT – The Pirates made a flurry of roster moves Monday as you are probably aware. Among the decisions was to keep Jose Contreras on the 25-man roster, and ship Bryan Morris back to Triple-A, to make room for Mike Zagurski.


Morris has options, Contreras does not. Earlier this year when addressing a similar situation, I believe it was with Jordy Mercer being sent back to Triple-A and John McDonald remaining on the roster, Pirate manager Clint Hurdle spoke about “asset allocation”


Hurdle indicated the Pirates are striving to keep as much depth and flexibility as possible. Indicating when one players has options and another does not, that will be a factor in the decision making. That’s logical … to an extent.


On Monday, 40-year-old Jose Contreras pitched like a 40-year-old. He allowed the pivotal runs in the seventh inning. He walked four and allowed two runs in 1/3 of an inning. Bryan Morris is probably not the second coming of Trevor Hoffman but it’s hard to believe he’s not a more valuable piece – his fastball averages 94 mph – than Contreras at this point in their careers. Wouldn’t the Pirates at least like to see what he can do in an extended Major League run?


Is Jose Contreras one of the Pirates’ top 25 players? Raise your hand if you think ‘yes.’


So after the Pirates’ Memorial Day loss to the Tigers, I asked Hurdle about the balancing act that is constructing a 25-man roster, maintaining flexibility and monitoring service-time issues, while fielding a competitive team.


Said Hurdle:  “When we make moves it’s always about having our best 25 guys in the Major Leagues … Always.”


I don’t believe that.


I believe as a manager, as a leader, you have to get behind the 25 guys in your clubhouse. You can’t always speak candidly to the media.


I get that.


It would be nice to have truth serum handy but it is what it is.


But I also get that it’s prudent, because of baseball’s bylaws, to not always have your 25 best men on the roster.


Let’s be honest here: Gerrit Cole and Jameson Taillon would make the Pirates better yesterday. But the Pirates are prudent to not have them at the Major League level…. yet to suppress service-time and free agency clocks. The patience will be worth while when the Pirates have those studs for another year in the prime.


It’s a tricky thing balance a 25-man roster with future and win-now interests. But with the Pirates off to their best start since 1991, I think the balance should be shifting to a win-now focus. I think Morris is a better fit on the 25-man roster than Contreras. I think Mercer can be more helpful than McDonald, who has made a good career for himself and is a good guy …but he’s an offensive liability. I think Gerrit Cole should be called up in the middle of June and given a shot to be an impact guy in the rotation. Maybe he’s saving his best for The Show.


The Pirates have often been a player development story, but now is the time to seize and opportunity.




I have a solution to some of the 25-man roster complications managers and front offices deal with: change service time requirements.


It’s in the game’s best interest – the players’, the fans’, the managers’ best interests – to have the best players on a roster.


What would put more big league-ready stars on rosters earlier in the season is a change to service time rules (something owners would be completely against).


But if you counted one day on a MLB roster as one year of service time, we would end this silliness about June until waiting until promotions. If a player is good enough to break camp with a club, he breaks camp. He is still eligible for arbitration in his fourth year of team control.


It this rule was in place, Gerrit Cole might be up. Wil Myers would be. Ditto for Zack Wheeler and Michael Wacha. It would give us a better rosters early in the season, it would give us a better game. Take comfort in the fact that it will never happen.



  1. Terry M says:

    LOL at your suggestion. The service time is one of the few parts of the labor contract that works in favor of the Pirates. So if they call a guy for an emergency start, he gets a year of service time? If they bring him up, start him two or three times and he’s clearly overmatched, you just burned a year of service time even though you send him back?

    Cole has 26 walks and 39 Ks at AAA. What makes you think he’s ready for the ML? How do you think that would have played against the lineup the Tigers had today?

  2. John Lease says:

    Contreras never should have been signed to begin with. Cut him loose.

  3. NMR says:

    Re-read what Travis wrote, Terry.
    “If a player is good enough to break camp with a club, he breaks camp. He is still eligible for arbitration in his fourth year of team control.”
    That would maintain the traditional three trips through arbitration and eliminate this silly Super-2 business.

  4. NMR says:

    I thought he could be useful eating up some middle innings with that forkball, but yeah, he’s looked bad.

  5. The players negotiated the Top 22% to get the extra year of arbitration.

    When was the last time you heard of the Players Union giving something up?

    Cue the Everly Brothers: “Dre-e-e-eam! Dream, Dream Dream!”

  6. Terry M says:

    What about free agency, which starts after six years? That’s the bigger issue.

  7. Chuck H says:

    Once again, Hurdle did not know when to yank a pitcher who was about to lose a game
    for the Bucs. I would have put out the hook after the first 2 guys walked. It was pretty obvious Contreras didn’t have good stuff, and it was wrong to even use him in a one run game. Maybe another pitcher wouldn’t have done any better, but the odds would have been better. Also, having 2 automatic outs hitting in succession (Inge and Barmes) did not help the Pirates either. In fact, Inge struck out 3 times. Why is he considered among the best 25???

  8. McCutch struck out 3 times the other night as well.
    Send both Inge and McCutch to Indy!!!

Other blogs
Sports: Rob Rossi | Steel Mill | Chipped Ice | Bucco Blog | iPreps | Pitt Locker Room | Penn State Sports
News: This Just In | Trib List | ICycle | Flow Back | Stories Behind Trib Stories  

» Top Sports » Top News » Top Breaking News