TribLIVE
Blogs | Sports | News
Dejan Kovacevic's Blog

Pittsburgh sports talk with the Trib columnist

« Font size »
Decrease | Reset |Increase

Morning Java: What were Reds thinking?

By Dejan Kovacevic | Trib Total Media

Morning, Lunatics …

>> The Wednesday column evaluates all that led to the Pirates’ long-awaited trade, including a little story about Dilson Herrera — the prospect sent to the Mets — that I’ve been saving for a while.

Brought that topic up with Neal Huntington yesterday …

Funny, but it also was brought up with the GM if he was surprised that Byrd had fallen to the Pirates, who have among the last waiver selections, without someone else — ahem, Reds — blocking it.

Huntington’s diplomatic answer after a slight laugh: “I have enough to worry about here that I don’t really worry about what other teams are doing.”

OK, then, I’ll say it: What were they thinking?

Forget the Cardinals. If you didn’t know, they actually had lower pecking order than the Pirates at the time of waivers, so they couldn’t have blocked. See St. Louis Post-Dispatch columnist Bernie Miklasz’s blog entry on the Pirates’ trade for more.

But Cincinnati is different. According to Huntington, the Pirates put in the waiver claim on Byrd within the previous 48 hours of the actual trade. Even if the Reds’ Walt Jocketty had no interest in Byrd — and you can understand why he wouldn’t, given Ryan Ludwick’s return — they had everything to gain by putting in claims and at least delaying or disrupting the process. Even if the Pirates still end up getting a crack, there would be more pressure to get a deal done by the Saturday deadline to set playoff rosters.

Really strange. And hard to explain.

Which might be why Cincinnati Enquirer blogger Steve Mancuso tried with just one word.

Anyway, here’s news coverage of the trade, by Rob Biertempfel.

Here’s the Mets’ perspective, by Adam Rubin of ESPN New York.

Here’s the game story from PNC Park last night, by Karen Price.

Here’s our full baseball coverage.

Here’s Brewers news from the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel.

Here are official game highlights from MLB.com.

>> It had been a while since Ryan Clark barked at the NFL. Alan Robinson reports on that, as well as how tomorrow night could bring a whole lot of Landry Jones. (Yippee.)

Isaac Redman and Jonathan Dwyer keep talking like the other isn’t in the room …

Here’s our full Steelers coverage.

>> This Pitt headline contains the amazing term ‘post-Sunseri era.’ Jerry DiPaola reflects.

>> Bill O’Brien won’t name his QB. Chris Adamski reports from State College.

>> Dana Holgorsen won’t, either. Bob Hertzel reports from Morgantown.

>> My TribLIVE Radio show is today at 2 p.m., featuring special guest Antonio Brown. I’ll have a full blog post up on this at around noon. Hope you can call in for the opening segment!

Author: Dejan Kovacevic

Dejan Kovacevic, a lifelong Pittsburgher, is an award-winning sports columnist for Trib Total Media covering the Steelers, Penguins, Pirates, Pitt and, recently, his fourth Olympics in Sochi, Russia. He also appears on WPXI-TV's 'Subway Final Word’ and hosts a weekly show on TribLIVE Radio. For 2011, he was named one of the country's top four columnists by the AP Sports Editors. For 2012, he was named one of the country's top three columnists by the National Headliners. For 2013, he was named the state's top columnist by the Keystone Press Awards and top columnist in Western Pennsylvania by the Golden Quills.

Comments

  1. Michael DE pitt says:

    Ode to Joy

  2. Michael DE pitt says:

    & as irishjim says
    Byrd is the word

  3. Tom P. says:

    Good analysis, DK. Thanks for the insight.

    Without stating the obvious, winning teams also find ways to win games like tonight, and those kinds of wins have eluded the Pirates recently. I think they will bounce back. Morton and Cole have pitched well in their last two starts. The Pirates were losing the first game of a series early in the season, but they found ways to win the next two or three. Maybe the addition of Byrd (and to a lesser extent Buck) will give them the extra offense needed to score one or two more runs a game.

    DK: Thanks.

  4. Thundercrack says:

    Nice article DK. And a lot of good insight.

    If at the end of March I would have told you that both Andrew Lambo and Felix Pie would be the corner outfielders at the end of the game on August 27 – what kind of season would you think we would be having?

    We should have won this game tonight.

    I thought Locke was decent for the first few innings but he needs his next start skipped.
    And what happened to Garret Jones? Right now he stinks.

    And I saw at the end of the game thread some were criticizing Gaby Sanchez. I hope that guy comes back next year. He is spectacular on defense. And he should start against left handed pitchers.

  5. Ghost says:

    Would quibble only in that Sanchez is not *spectacular* on defense. He misses on some throws and doesn’t snag everything hit in his direction. But he has shown to be a decent defender and his bat has (hopefully) rounded the corner. If he can be re-signed for a reasonable price for 1-2 years, then I agree with you about getting him back. A winning team needs guys who accept role-playing jobs and I sense Gaby is one of those kind of guys.

  6. DJ says:

    Walker’s comments being misinterpreted as him being unhappy about the trade?

    I like Neil and have always wanted him to see him succeed, but Dilson Herrera moving out as one of our better infielder prospects — even if a couple years away — only enhances Walker’s value to the team over the longer term. I suspect Neil is pleased.

    DK: Wow. No. Just no. See below.

  7. theplanisworking says:

    Dejan, great column as always.

    Interesting to see the question of what were other teams thinking……..

    Personally, I dont care what other teams are thinking.
    Or doing. Or not doing.
    I care about what the Pirates do or dont do.
    Yesterday was good. A little late for most peoples tastes, but…………..

    Now that we have addressed the bat issue, I am concerned going forward with the pitching. Not exactly building confidence with some recent perfromances.

    Pirates are 6-11 in their past 17 games.
    4-4 in their last 8……. against 3 bottom feeder teams.
    With the additions of Byrd and Buck, the pitching issues must be immediately addressed. Get Locke out of there, put Cumpton or Gomez in. The expansion of the rosters to 40 for September will help the pitching.

    Now, its time to win some da$n games.

  8. Daquido_Bazzini says:

    I’m not blaming the loss on Gaby Sanchez, but didn’t I see him fail to corral a fly pop up down the line late in the game?
    I’m always amazed to see how some continually praise Sanchez (a marginal player)….And then turn around and damn Neil Walker.

  9. Daquido_Bazzini says:

    Agreed about other teams.
    I’m glad to see Huntington do something, but it should’ve been done this time last month.
    I just hope it isn’t too late.

  10. theplanisworking says:

    First, he was a utility player.
    Then a super-utility players.
    Then was denied a promotion to the bigs over not running out an infield-fly rule popup!!
    Then, he was a stop-gap.
    Then he didnt have enough range.
    Then he couldnt hit enough to stay.
    Then you cant criticize him because he is “The Pittsburgh Kid”.
    Then he was wrong with his comments at trade deadlines.

    The kid cant catch a break.
    But the same people who have relentlessly criticized him will be the first bit%%ing once he is gone.

    I hope Neil sticks around and has a great career……… just to stick it to his critics.

  11. Ghost says:

    Yes DK, you struck just the right note in your column. I too, was content with Huntington’s patience at the non-waiver deadline. He was beginning to make me squirm as this month’s last-chance deadline was quickly approaching and these losses in August were adding up. But he rewarded my new-found faith in his stewardship as he did, in fact, pull the trigger once a sensible move was in front of him.

    I also have always sensed that as the expiration date on any trade value for Justin Morneau draws nearer, Twins just may talk real turkey. I still wonder if Morneau has had cold feet about coming to the Pirates. And I do wonder about the abrupt influx (and “out”-flux) of too many players into the club house. But for now, I gotta believe that Marlon Byrd is going to be warmly welcomed, and that Byrd, himself, has to be pretty happy being sought out as a difference maker.

    DK: Thanks!

  12. Lad9 says:

    Daq

    I was there and had a real good look at Gaby chasing that pop up. There is no possible way that he could have put more effort into than he did. It would have been an unbelievable play had he made it. No issue with him not getting it.

    As for Neil, I agree and don’t understand why he takes some of the heat he does. He is such an intelligent player. Yes he got thrown out tagging up and it was a mistake, but he took a chance. He made a wonderful play getting Segura at third. I have been watching baseball for a long time and I have no memory of ever having seen that happen. And the HR was killed and it was clutch. He is a good solid player, I love him settled in the 2 hole, and I am glad he is on my team. I m sure many other teams would also be thrilled to have him. Now if he can fix the righty hitting….

  13. Ghost says:

    I gotta believe Walker was referring to Tony Sanchez and whomever else will be removed from the 25-man.
    Perfectly understandable sentiment, if not exactly media-savvy.

    DK: It was EXACTLY media-savvy in that he recognized a question he felt could be turned against him with the wrong answer and immediately balked.

    Is this still really being discussed?

    He didn’t want to celebrate two teammates LOSING THEIR JOBS. These guys aren’t fans. They’re friends and teammates.

    This is NOT complicated.

  14. Lad9 says:

    +18 Plan. You nailed it better than I did. Thank you.

  15. Stuart says:

    Tough loss again tonight.

    What has happened to Jones?

    Tabby should have had that ball.

    Pedro & Neil heating up?

    Hoping the PTBNL is JMAC.

    Feeling very positive about the trade.

    Very nice column DK!

    Stuart

    DK: Thanks, Stu.

    I love some of the PTBNL names that have been floated. It’s always the absolute least favorite player on the roster.

    It’s actually Zagurski!

  16. Eric Bowser says:

    * Sigh….. at the thought of Jones or Sanchez needing to come up with a hit when this thing gets real.

    * My expectations of Byrd are quite simple. Continue to play like he did in New York and be a professional. Same with Buck.

    * Whenever I see or hear the name Ryan Clark, I’m immediately ready to turn the page, turn off the radio or tv.

    * Since no one in Pittsburgh seems able to stay healthy at RB for Steelers or Panthers, maybe both teams will come out throwing the ball more than we think.

    * USA Olympic hockey jersey….. I mean really, can Nike just keep to shoes and stop screwing up jerseys, helmets, logos, etc.

    * Have to end this on a positive note… Pedro Alvarez and Neil Walker had themselves quite the offensive performance last night against Milwaukee. Nothing sweeter than Walker’s swing and crack of the bat on his HR that went out of the ball park.

  17. Lad9 says:

    DK

    I have now read the column twice and still feel like I could go back and pull a few more items out to chew on. You put a lot of content in a small space, and I really enjoyed this one. Thank you for switching your day off to get this to us, and for packing this column so chock full of tasty nuggets.

    As a nice side benefit for you too, the next time someone accuses you of not being objective in regards to the Pirate front office, just link to this column. It may not shut them up or convince them, but then again, the OJ jury acquitted him too. No satisfying some people.

    For my part, thank you once more for your hard work and for your outstanding writing. I am a lunatic and proud of it!

    DK: Thanks, Lad. There are exactly 46 people, by my count, who accuse me of the objectivity thing. Amazing how a tiny, tiny few can be so squeaky and noisy, but that’s the number: 46.

    Really appreciated your line, in particular, about stuffing a lot in there. Reminds me of what all I chopped onto the cutting-room floor.

  18. Arriba Wilver says:

    I can’t speak for anybody but me, but I thought Neil said the wrong thing today. But at least for me it is a misinterpretation of my criticism to say I interpreted it as him being unhappy with the trade. I didn’t think that at all. Like Ghost says, it wasn’t media savvy IMHO. Didn’t suggest cutting him, benching him, didn’t call his parents names, just thought it was the wrong thing to say. And I doubt I’m alone in that thinking or in not thinking he was upset. I was surprised when I read DK’s interpretation of the criticism, but I don’t tweet. Maybe I have a thing with Neal’s/Neil’s and their communication with the media. But Neil’s usually much better. ;-)

  19. Arriba Wilver says:

    They did pretty well defensively, too. Some nice plays.

  20. Ghost says:

    Re: Byrd — “…play like he did in New York and be a professional…”

    Every time he comes up to bat, he’s going to sliiiiiiiide into the box just like Morris Day and the Time did performing “The Bird” in Purple Rain.

    DK: John Buck will hold his mirror.

  21. Eric Bowser says:

    Yep, spend hours to days running down a story and then have to condense it into a few hundred words on a deadline.

    Imagine putting all that lost information into a place that supplement the reader… the beauty of social media… and at the same time, exactly what many fail to understand in the microwave society that those 46 or other “fine” bloggers think their hour of typing an article derived from the hard work of others. I think that’s why folks are beat reporters… beaten to death….

    ….I wonder how many of them could handle reporting under a deadline and offer news, opinion, etc. without seeming repetitive and mundane in their writing.

  22. Eric Bowser says:

    I’m negative…. shocker…. didn’t like Tabata’s attempt that ultimately ended Locke’s night and really needed Sanchez to catch that ball in 8th but yes, Pedro had a nice play diving to his left and Walker’s decision to throw to third base.

    Oh yeah, there was also the Mercer drop on a gimme double play.

  23. Ghost says:

    I entirely get why he would feel this way: I said so in above post. But his remark was obviously NOT media-savvy, precisely because this did become a topic of conversation. A more savvy response would not have included the words, “I can’t say I’m happy…”

    Now, I wasn’t around today so I have no idea how much or little it has been discussed. The first I heard of it was your mention of it in the column. But I can immediately see how this would have become something that titillated some. I thought my above post made it clear that I, myself, have no problem with Walker’s sentiment towards his teammates.

  24. Ghost says:

    Since you got that reference, you clearly are one of the “sexy people!”

  25. irishjim says:

    Indeed!

  26. Ghost says:

    Should add that I don’t think it’s easy for athletes to spontaneously answer difficult questions, or that I, myself, could have done any better. That was a classic scene in Bull Durham when Crash Davis instructed Nuke LaLoosh on how to answer reporters’ questions with boilerplate phrases.

  27. Ghost says:

    “…the additions of Byrd and Buck…”

    You just like them because they remind you of bird shot and buck shot.
    http://ih3.redbubble.net/image.9071260.1022/fc,550×550,white.jpg

  28. Brandie says:

    DK,

    Thank you for the great read. No doubt Neil Walker has mixed feelings about the business of baseball…happy to be in a playoff race, but not happy about some of the moves made to jockey for position.

    Once again, thank you for going the extra mile.

  29. 21sthebest says:

    +1

    I just thought he could have chosen his words a little better.

  30. Drew71 says:

    I’m GLAD Neil Walker said what he said. Now if the season crumbles, we’ll have someone to blame.

    We’ll call him Operation SitTFDown.

  31. 21sthebest says:

    I think if DK is accused of not being objective, he should just completely ignore that criticism.

  32. Drew71 says:

    He’ll NEED a new nickname.

    Cause Pine Richland just called.

    They told me to tell Neil that they want their name back.

  33. Drew71 says:

    Next time he K’s with men on base, I think I’m gonna post

    Happy Now?

  34. Drew71 says:

    I hope you’re not counting ME in that 46.

    That is, as long as we’re just talking about being objective. And not about occasionally being grumpy, snippy, over the top talking building-like.

    But no. Not questioning objectivity.

    There. Glad I could offer my support.

    (Why does this feel like a family thanksgiving dinner discussion?)

  35. Tom P. says:

    With 31 games left, the Pirates magic number to eliminate Arizona is 24, to host the wild card is 28 (vs. Reds) and to win the division is 33 (vs. Cardinals).

  36. John Lease says:

    So, everyone who thought I was panicking for no reason when the tankage started, what say ye now?

    It is ALWAYS time to panic, when it comes to the Pirates. If I didn’t care, I wouldn’t panic.

  37. Thundercrack says:

    If you are talking to me I didn’t criticize Walker’s play in the field. He had a great game.

  38. Thundercrack says:

    Wow. We’re really going to start this all over again?

    Nobody criticized Walker’s play. Some of us didn’t appreciate his comments at last year’s deadline and didn’t like them this year either.
    And DK has said that Walker’s comments this year are being misinterpreted.

    But I also think that if you are going to tag up from first you better be safe

  39. Thundercrack says:

    I was at the game and was 11 rows from where Sanchez missed the pop fly in the 8th. It was an extremely tough play.

    And no one called for it. Not Walker, not Sanchez and not Lambo.
    I was that close.

  40. Wild Bill says:

    Some thoughts as I woke up too early a while ago:

    Boy did we miss Marte in left last night. The Brewers ran on Tabata’s arm and he missed at least one Marte would have had easily.

    It’s hard to lose when you get 15 hits and six runs, but its hard to win when you give up 14 and seven. Nine left on base again. Overall, an unusual game for the 2013 Bucs, the hitting was better than the pitching. A “man bites dog” story.

    Glad for the trade, but I have no problem with Walker’s comments. Byrd and Buck haven’t been in the battle with the team for the last six months like some guys who will get moved out – at least temporarily.

    If I’m a Brewers player, I wouldn’t like the way Kyle Lohse showed up teammates when things went wrong for them a couple times. Maybe he’s gone this week.

    Morneau could be the next Ludwick if he doesn’t really want to leave Minnesota. I’d be very wary of him if I were Neal.

    Thanks to DK for his column and for getting us stirred up once again!

  41. Wild Bill says:

    And unfortunately, the Cards are starting to play like the pennant race seasoned team that they are.

  42. Mike A. says:

    +1

  43. Mike A. says:

    I know this is probably 21 years of frustration and conditioned response talking, but I’m going to make two predictions based on what I’ve seen over the past couple weeks of this season: 1. The Pirates will struggle to win 90 games this year. In other words, I don’t expect them to win more than 13 of their remaining games. Tonight, the cracks in the bullpen were the final straw. 2. There will not be any playoff games played at PNC Park in 2013. A “One and Done” in Cincinnati is what I foresee. Hope to be wrong…but I’m not optimistic. Again, after the last 20 years, how can I be anything but a pessimist.

  44. BillyBaduka says:

    Could you please pass me the mashed potatoes?

  45. JAL says:

    JAL’s Tin Man Morning Links

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7uJL8er_tV0

    GENERAL DAILY UPDATED BASEBALL SITES

    1- MLB Transactions

    http://www.cbssports.com/mlb/transactions

    2-MLB Trade Rumors-Pirates

    http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/pittsburgh_pirates/

    3 Pittsburgh Pirates Stats

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AsjN0zO-DxI0dHVOMzdPYm9wUEJtdVJ0WWUzVWhFc2c#gid=0

    BLOGS and such

    4—Pirates Prospects

    First Pitch: Trades Are Graded on a Different Scale For Contenders

    http://www.piratesprospects.com/2013/08/first-pitch-trades-are-graded-on-a-different-scale-for-contenders.html

    Pirates’ Comeback Attempt Fails in ‘Strange Game’, Lose 7-6 to Brewers

    http://www.piratesprospects.com/2013/08/pirates-comeback-attempt-fails-in-strange-game-lose-7-6-to-brewers.html

    Prospect Watch: Taillon Strikes Out Six; Polanco Hits 12th Homer

    http://www.piratesprospects.com/2013/08/prospect-watch-taillon-strikes-out-six-polanco-hits-12th-homer.html

    5 Bucs Dugout

    Locke has another tough outing, Bucs fall to Brewers 7-6

    http://www.bucsdugout.com/2013/8/27/4666476/locke-has-another-tough-outing-bucs-fall-to-brewers-7-6

    6 Rumbunter

    Pirates Bag Byrd, Buck

    http://rumbunter.com/2013/08/27/pirates-acquire-marlon-byrd-john-buck-cash-for-dilson-herrera-ptbnl/

    7 WHYGAVS

    Game 130: Brewers 7 Pirates 6

    http://cityofchampionssports.com/2013/08/26/great-scot-pittsburgh-pirates-and-the-law-of-averages/

    8 The Green Weenie

    Brewers Second Wind Blows Past Pirates 7-6

    http://oldbucs.blogspot.com/2013/08/brewers-second-wind-blows-past-pirates.html

    9 Raise the Jolly Roger

    Brewers 7, Pirates 6

    http://raisethejollyroger.com/2013/08/brewers-7-pirates-6/

  46. JAL says:

    NEWSPAPERS and MAGAZINES and Other Media

    10 City of Champions

    Pittsburgh Pirates: Why pitching will determine NL Central Crown

    http://cityofchampionssports.com/2013/08/27/pittsburgh-pirates-why-pitching-will-determine-nl-central-crown/

    11 New York Daily News

    Mets trade Marlon Byrd, who just had promotion day at Citi Field, and John Buck to Pirates for SS prospect Dilson Herrera

    http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/baseball/mets/mets-ship-byrd-buck-pittsburgh-article-1.1438423

    12 Rant Sports

    Pittsburgh Pirates Make Great Move Acquiring Marlon Byrd

    http://www.rantsports.com/mlb/2013/08/27/pittsburgh-pirates-make-great-move-acquiring-marlon-byrd/

    13 Baseball Nation

    Pirates-Mets trade: Bucs add Byrd and Buck, Mets get a lot younger

    http://www.baseballnation.com/2013/8/27/4665476/pittsburgh-pirates-new-york-mets-trade-marlon-byrd-john-buck-dilson-herrera

    14 Milwaukee Journal Sentinel/b>

    Aramis Ramirez lifts Brewers over Pirates

    http://www.jsonline.com/sports/brewers/aramis-ramirez-lifts-brewers-over-pirates-b9984688z1-221428951.html

    15 Cincinnati Enquirer

    Reds fall again to Cardinals, 6-1

    http://news.cincinnati.com/article/20130827/SPT04/308270059/Reds-fall-again-to-Cardinals-6-1

    16 CBS Sports

    Brewers-Pirates Gam Preview

    http://www.cbssports.com/mlb/gametracker/preview/MLB_20130828_MIL@PIT

    17 St Louis Post Dispatch

    Bonus Bytes: Trade boosts the Pirates

    http://www.stltoday.com/sports/columns/bernie-miklasz/bonus-bytes-trade-boosts-the-pirates/article_60271324-a32f-5311-8745-e2ec252323a2.html

    18 PBC Site

    Bucs lose ground in Central after Locke’s rough start

    http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/gameday/index.jsp?gid=2013_08_27_milmlb_pitmlb_1&mode=recap_home&c_id=pit

    Notebook: Marte able to avoid surgery on right hand

    http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20130827&content_id=58630816&notebook_id=58630820&vkey=notebook_pit&c_id=pit

    SPORTS WEBSITES

    19 Baseball Prospectus

    Reworking WARP The Overlooked Uncertainty of Offense

    http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=21656

    20 Fangraphs

    Pirates Land Marlon Byrd, as Upgrade, in 2013

    http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/pirates-land-marlon-byrd-as-upgrade-in-2013/

    A.J. Burnett’s Not So Secret Weapon

    http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/aj-burnetts-not-so-secret-weapon/

  47. JAL says:

    Steelers Blogs

    21 Behind the Steel Curtain

    NFL looking to ‘take action’ on low hits, Steelers Ryan Clark reacts

    http://www.behindthesteelcurtain.com/2013/8/28/4667032/steelers-ryan-clark-comments-nfl-low-hits-dustin-keller-fine-penalty

    Guard Ramon Foster has earned Steelers respect

    http://www.behindthesteelcurtain.com/2013/8/27/4664676/Steelers-offensive-line-guard-Ramon-Foster

    22 Steelers Depot

    Rotation Gameplan at Outside Linebacker Evident

    http://www.steelersdepot.com/2013/08/rotation-gameplan-at-outside-linebacker-evident-in-third-preseason-game/

    Soccer(football)

    23 Evening Standard

    Theo Walcott: Tottenham are still not better than us

    http://www.standard.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/theo-walcott-tottenham-are-still-not-better-than-us-8787505.html

    24 World Soccer Daily

    10 stories you need to read, 27th August, 2013

    http://www.worldsoccer.com/247/world-soccer-daily-10-stories-you-need-to-read-27th-august-2013

    PENGUIN BLOGS and NHL Links

    25 Pensburgh

    Pens Points 8/28: The Skinny on Pouliot, Letang’s New Year Resolution

    http://www.pensburgh.com/2013/8/28/4664988/pens-points-8-28-the-skinny-on-pouliot-letangs-new-year-resolution

  48. JAL says:

    Tin Man America 1974

  49. Mike A. says:

    Oh, and BTW…What were the Reds thinking? They were thinking that the Pirates are not a legitimate threat…and they are probably right.

  50. meglasdad says:

    Maybe this offseason when they are taking a break from carrying telephone poles in the sand, they can have a session or two on how to handle the media? ;) Sorry, couldn’t help myself.

  51. pattonbb says:

    “Hold on now, this dance ain’t for everybody. Just the sexy people”……

  52. theplanisworking says:

    Oh we oh we oh!

  53. Milo Hamilton says:

    Where are we now ?

    - Since August 9th the Pirates are 6-11 and have lost 5.5 games in the standings (Only 6 of those games were against teams with winning records).

    - Last year starting on August 9th they went 5-12 and lost 6.5 games in the standings.

    This needs to end now so I can stop looking this stuff up.

  54. theplanisworking says:

    Extra Mile?
    The man runs a marathon every day!

    We get the benefit of that running on his part, and we dont even supply him a water cup!

  55. theplanisworking says:

    You posted this last night.
    Now you post this today.

    Maybe YOU are jinxing them? ;)

  56. Jandy says:

    haha good pic ;)

  57. Milo Hamilton says:

    By the way, the Diamondbacks apparently didn’t get the memo that Ian Kennedy was back to his old self – 4.1 IP 6 ER. Just revisiting the excuse from last Wednesday’s loss.

  58. Jandy says:

    + many and oodles!

  59. Milo Hamilton says:

    I’m working on the reverse jinx theory. I want people to come after me if they turn it around and call me a non-believer. Notice I said “if” they turn it around. I ain’t convinced.

  60. Jandy says:

    YOu want gravy with that?

  61. Jandy says:

    I’m not panicking :)

  62. Jandy says:

    82 is the magic number :)

  63. theplanisworking says:

    +1

  64. Jandy says:

    I’m spinning round, round, round, round.

    (No wonder I’m dizzy)

  65. Jandy says:

    and won’t they kick their own butts when they find out otherwise :)

  66. Jandy says:

    OK Loonies, got tons of paperwork, I’ll check in later on….enjoy the morning :)

  67. theplanisworking says:

    Last year in September, Pirates went 7-21.
    2011, Pirates went 10-16.

    Just sayin’

  68. theplanisworking says:

    I really dont know how Ghost, and Brandie come up with this stuff.

    But it is hella funny……….

  69. theplanisworking says:

    Dont blame it on the spinning, sister…………..

  70. theplanisworking says:

    Wow. We are really going to question this again?

    Look, all I was pointing out was that Neil gets critcized for almosy everything, which includes his words, AND his play. For some “fans”, he can do no right. Neil’s choice of words has gotten criticism from some, which is their right. But, when neal H. says some bad things, he gets a pass from those same people. Dont you find that a bit odd?

    My post wasnt directed toward any one poster, it was a general statement. But it is curious how some get offended when this subject is brought up.

    Unless your first line is being directed at me just to be contrarian.

  71. Stuart says:

    DK, if true it must be that they admire Ron’s “svelte-itude”. it certainly wouldn’t be difficult to assemble a long list of PWHIWB (players we hope it will be).

    Stuart

  72. Brandie says:

    Pleasantly disturbing.

  73. theplanisworking says:

    ” And no one called for it. Not Walker, not Sanchez and not Lambo. ”

    This brings up an interesting point. As far back as Little League, players are taught to call for fly balls, so you dont go crashing into each other. I wonder if this play in particular is another example of lack of fundamentals? Someone should have called for that. And, I am not criticizing Gaby at all. That was an extremely difficult play for him to make.

  74. Arriba Wilver says:

    +1

  75. Arriba Wilver says:

    Wasn’t clear, but I was referring strictly to your last paragraph about Alvarez and Walker.

  76. Brandie says:

    Well, work on that, Plan!

  77. theplanisworking says:

    Morning, Muppet.

    I need help with the water cups for DK.

  78. pattonbb says:

    non-believer.

    Oh wait, I’m supposed to wait until they turn it around before I call you that? Oops.

    I’m not convinced either, Milo. But I like this lineup a lot more today than I did a coupe days ago. Marlon won’t be the “Byrd that saved Pittsburgh”, but he’s an immediate upgrade.

    Charlie stops the bleeding tonight.

  79. Brandie says:

    And Derek Bell was called

    Operation Shut TF Down.

    I’d rather have Neil Walker any day.

  80. Brandie says:

    You got it.

    ( As Chariots of Fire plays while we hand DK cups of water. )

  81. Thundercrack says:

    Going all the way back to when Walker was called up and when he was labeled a utility player.

    And I thought it was NH who took the criticism for that back then.

  82. Brandie says:

    BYRRRRD MAAAAAN!

  83. Drew71 says:

    No. Just a little ipecac.

  84. Reaching “2nd Base” is only exciting for a 14 year old boy!

    82 is no magic number for me.

    It’s been 20 years! I’m not 14 any more. I want to go all the way!!

  85. radio wave says:

    Great article DK. No issue with Walker’s position.

  86. Dom says:

    Byrd is the word.

  87. Milo Hamilton says:

    Where are we now ?

    Having to rely on Charlie Morton.

  88. 21sthebest says:

    Bingo.

  89. 21sthebest says:

    I’d like to hear names of posters who criticize Walker but give Huntington a pass.

  90. Jandy says:

    Walker also bobbled that same ball before he passed it awkwardly to Mercer.

  91. Brandie says:

    Someone help this man!

  92. twentytwo22 says:

    http://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/PIT/1990-schedule-scores.shtml

    Here’s a positive Pirates flashback. In 1990, they lost to fall out of first place 1/2 games behind the Mets. They were 75-56. They won 3 games in a row to go ahead by 1/2 games and then swept the Mets in a 3 game series at home including a DH sweep. They were 81-56 an 3.5 games in 1st.

    The current Pirates will win this series and then win the series against St. Louis and they will be in first place.

    If they survive their personal demons of August and September they will reach the playoffs a stronger team than their competition. No other team has this kind of baggage.

  93. Milo Hamilton says:

    Where’s irishjim ? :)

  94. 21sthebest says:

    Sometimes you just have one of those pop flies that a bunch of players go after figuring that someone might have a better shot and nobody ends up calling it. Not a fundamental problem, IMO, but I put this one in the That’s Baseball category.

  95. Brotherhood of the Redus says:

    The Pirates are unimpressed with the Cards starting rotation. Watch an ye shall see. Will be the wild west around here this weekend.

  96. 21sthebest says:

    I’ve never seen any good come out if panicking, so I don’t.

  97. Lad9 says:

    I will hand him the Starbucks… :)

  98. Wild Bill says:

    BotR, Here’s hoping you’re right.

  99. Brotherhood of the Redus says:

    See it, feel it, be it

  100. Drew71 says:

    I have a bad feeling about tonight’s game.

    A Bad Karma thing.

    In nerdy Star Trek terms, almost as if matter and anti-matter are coming together. Same place. Same time.

    Nerdy is right.

  101. theplanisworking says:

    HA!

    BTW, you and Thunder are fired!
    You 2 didnt bring back a W last night.

    NO SOUP FOR YOU !!!

  102. Brandie says:

    Thank you, Lad 9! :-)

    Already gave the BIRDMAN yell today.

    Welcome also to Buck Wild / Buck Rogers / Buck Owens / Buck Naked / Buck Henry / Buck Cherry / Buck O’Neil!

  103. theplanisworking says:

    Better than relying on his dog……. ;)

  104. Nate83 says:

    I don’t know if I’m on the list, I don’t know if there even is a list. I don’t really care if there is a list.

    I will only say that it takes two to tango and I have been accused by DK himself of not being objective and blindly supporting the GM. When he does that it frustrates me because I have questioned and disagreed with many moves made by the GM. Just because my opinion does not agree with him on most things GM doesn’t mean I don’t think he is being objective. It also doesn’t mean I’m not being objective and should get a bold text response telling me I will stop at nothing to support the GM instead of just sticking to the one topic or move we may be debating.

    Trust me when I say this was meant in no way to speak badly about DK. I love his columns and agree with almost everything he writes. It was just to point out that sometimes I have felt he has done to others what he thinks “46″ are doing to him. Just my two cents which I think will probably get at least a couple dimes thrown back at me really hard.

  105. “I need more power, Scotty! You’ve got to get me more power!!”

  106. You have just made me drop US$ 1.29 on iTunes. :)

  107. DJ says:

    I understand Walker was referring to two players on the major league roster and expressing sentiment for them (which was not the focus of my comment). However, it’s time to put on the big boy pants, realize this is what happens with competitive teams at the major league level and then have the resolve and mental toughness to produce (like last night) because we’re in a division race. He’s had a disappointing year although he’s improved since the All Star break. He needs to keep it going and his confidence level up.

    Neil is at a crossroads. A few years ago he envisioned himself in a small group of core players that the team would build around long-term. The club rightfully has taken a wait-and-see approach and which I believe has shaken a bit of his confidence. Having less internal options down the road (like Herrera) enhances Walker’s value, which should please him (my only point).

  108. Brotherhood of the Redus says:

    HAHA on the Red’s blog someone actually made the statement that Walt Jocketystrap didn’t block the Byrd trade because he could have been stuck with him and as a result might have had to cut Xavier Paul loose???

    I hope Xavier Paul doesn’t pull a Sid Bream on the Bucs in that one game playoff or, better yet in a division series….but Xavier Paul???? What is it that I am missing? OBP in the .300′s but can’t steal bases….strikes out quite a bit….is he still clutch as a late inning bat off the bench?

  109. Milo Hamilton says:

    Wasn’t his name Bailey ?

  110. Now——right now——the Pirates prove if they really have heart.

    Huntington did his job.

  111. Brandie says:

    Jean Luc Picard with head in hands.

  112. theplanisworking says:

    Not from me you wont. I have no coins. ;)

    On a serious note, maybe it is possible for posters to constantly agree/disagree with something, then when they are called out for it, they do an about-face and deny everything?? I have seen that many times on here. Not pointing you out, but I have seen it from some.

    I think the fact that some of the “46″ are maybe looking for an angle to support their positions, that they accuse DK, and others of not being objective? I dont know, but sometimes I feel that way.

    Like I said, no coins at you…… I’m broke.

  113. Carries around Zuzu’s petals in his pocket.

  114. theplanisworking says:

    DAMMIT JIM, I’M A DOCTOR, NOT A MIRACLE WORKER !!

  115. Tom P. says:

    ESPN reports that the Pirates’ two moves to make room for Byrd and Buck on the 40 man roster are to DFA Russ Canzler and to put Kyle McPherson on the 60 Day DL.

    The corresponding moves on the 25 man roster will be announced today. Seeing as rosters expand to 40 on Sunday, the moves will only result in a short demotion for two people. My guess is those two people are T. Sanchez and Lambo.

    Because rosters expand on Sunday, it might be time to give Cumpton a start in place of Locke. I like the saying that players make the lineup (by performing), and Locke just hasn’t give anyone a reason to put him in lineup for awhile.

  116. Brandie says:

    Now let’s go violate the Prime Directive!

  117. pattonbb says:

    Yes. That’s exactly where we are. Relying on the best Pirate starting pitcher over the last 4 weeks.

    I know how insane that sounds. But the guy’s been tough as nails for a month now.

  118. Lad9 says:

    That is exactly what it was 21. Because if you call two other people off when you yourself can’t reach the ball, THAT is a problem with fundamentals.

  119. 21sthebest says:

    I agree. I’ve seen that happen.

  120. Dom says:

    Sounds good to me.

  121. Dom says:

    What kind of a dr are you?

  122. Lad9 says:

    Yes, we should be fired. No soup, no Primanti’s. I lost my last one too, and I am scheduled to go again on Sunday. I am slotted in Jeff Locke’s rotation spot apparently.

    I have to do something to break out of this slump. Hmmm, Brandie maybe we should dress up as the Pirate’s new super hero, Byrd Man, and sit in the Byrd’s nest behind him. Of course by Sunday if Byrd hasn’t had two walk off hits and gone 10-12 in his first three Pirate games, the night trolls will be calling for him to be DFA’d and will want to bring up Presley or bring back Casey McGehee or Adam Hyzdu…

  123. Milo Hamilton says:

    I kinda liked Xavier Paul but geez. And just like what will happen here, whoever you cut you can bring back on Sunday.

  124. Baywatch says:

    Come on, Pirates! You’re STILL 21 games over .500 at just about the September mark but the .500 winning percentage since July 1 really makes us feel like LOSERS again! We like to keep it REAL in Pittsburgh. The overall record, matched up with the way things REALLY are has us feeling like we’re the good guys stepping out with one of those sorority girls in Animal House! Let’s win this thing going away!

  125. Kevin says:

    Morneau is no Jarome Iginla. FREE MORNEAU!

  126. Baywatch says:

    Like! What a comeback story Charlie’s would be if he can finish the year strong! Really pullin’ for the guy. Seems he’s got a whole lot more to overcome than just Tommy John. Well, like the other Pirates: This whole LOSING THING!

  127. JohninOshkosh says:

    Known and sanctioned PED user comes to town. Everybody excited. No cute nicknames like “Lying Ryan.”

    Guess I know the answer to Dejan’s Pirates and PED question posed earlier this summer.

    As Jerry Seinfeld observed, you are cheering for laundry.

  128. Baywatch says:

    What if JMac turns out to be the ace in the hole on the back side of the stretch! YEAH, RIGHT, BAY! That would be a split-finger no one would see comin’!

  129. Karen22 says:

    TOUCHE!! And good morning to all!

    Excellent column. One bat need addressed (but still need to get Jones off of first and OUT of the lineup entirely)…on to some pitching issues, of which Locke is MAJOR. I was shocked he actually got yesterday’s start after his consistently dreadful 2nd half. He needs to sit for a good, long while. I believe his confidence is presently completely shot, and we cannot go into the final stretch with him on the mound every 5th day. CANNOT.

    Oh – and that goes for Jared Hughes and Bryan Morris in the bullpen. I don’t want to see either of them coming when the game’s on the line!

  130. Nice Wonderful Life reference, Groaty.

  131. Nate83 says:

    Yes they would have been “stuck” with a well above average defensive right/left fielder who hits for both average and good power. I wish we were stuck with such players. Wait a minute……when Marte come back we will be stuck with 3 of those guys.

    I like the move. Hopefully they can get a first baseman as well or Jones somehow figures it out.

  132. Even miracle man Charlie can’t do it by himself. Need some of that thing that doesn’t exist–clutch hitting.

  133. “I’m a priest, not a saint”–Richard Harris in The Count of Monte Christo

  134. Milo Hamilton says:

    They could start by making the routine plays.

  135. Dom says:

    What’s the answer at first?

    Jones and Gabby stink.

    I saw that Morneau was 2 for his last 19.

    Kornerko’s #s are similar to the guys we got.

  136. That amen, brother was for Milo.

  137. Milo Hamilton says:

    Tom Gorzelanny’s last 2 starts:

    8.1 IP 16 H 12 ER 12.96 ERA

    Uh oh.

  138. Kevin says:

    welp, I think no matter what, the FO is absolved of any poor outcome to the rest of the season. The great off-season and now a trade to address NEEDS before September.

    The pieces are there… its up to them to start performing.

    Wouldn’t it be funny for our hitting to start coming around with Pedro, Neil, and Cutch, (and Byrd), and now our starting pitching to start crumble? Well not funny… but, our iron man of the 1st half, Locke, has been unlocked. Even our new staff ACE, Liriano, has shown some holes lately. And like someone said above, can’t believe Morton is now the pitcher in which we rally around.

    Sustainability and the law of averages coming back to bite us with all these 1-run losses. And we’re finding different ways to do it too. Which is just fantastic. Hopefully with Grilli coming back, we’ll get back the best setup/8th inning pitcher of the year (Melancon) and that will swing the equation back to our favor.

  139. Naterosboro says:

    If you’re giving chase though and feel you can’t make a play on the ball, you don’t call it. You only call the ball if you think you can catch it.

    Sounds like the ball was hit in a perfect spot between 3 of our fielders.

    It happens.

    I do not think the Pirates did anything wrong fundamentally on the play (if it is as described here by other posters; I did not see the play in question).

  140. Naterosboro says:

    +1

  141. Jandy says:

    And I’m Mother Theresa! ;)

  142. Nate83 says:

    Good points all around Kevin. I think Locke needs to skip a start and then be on a short leash after that. He has clearly shown he more then likely will not be part of the rotation for any playoff series we might play. The 6 or 7 starts he has remaining are important games. Gomez and Crumpton have both proven capable of doing enough to warrent not pitching Locke the rest of the year if he doesn’t show signs of figuring it out soon.

  143. Naterosboro says:

    Assures him of 7IP 4H 1R 7Ks.

  144. Jandy says:

    When was Byrd using PED’s, Oshkosh? I’m asking because I don’t know his history.

  145. Bob Hasis says:

    With all of the goings on last night in a poorly played game, and IrishJims Byrd Song,
    I forgot to ask this question;
    Why was Tabby in left field – not right field – when Ramirez scorched that shot over his out-stretched glove to drive in two critical runs?

    Was that an “automatic” decision by the “Manager of the Year in waiting”? Tabby has enough trouble in right, so don’t tell me left is better for him.

    That little misjudgment was very damaging to our best interests in last night’s game

  146. Milo Hamilton says:

    Arizona’s only 5 games behind the Reds. I’ll stop there.

  147. Same as Richard Harris was a priest or a saint.

    ;)

  148. JohninOshkosh says:

    Suspended 50 games last year for banned substance. An estrogen blocking substance ie a steroid masker.

  149. Lambo don’t do left field. Neither does Jones.

  150. Milo Hamilton says:

    Tells you how bad Lambo is.

  151. Jandy says:

    Zactly!

  152. JohninOshkosh says:

    I watched the end of that game. That was a big win for the D-Backs. Picked up a game on the Pirates. They are just sort of quietly hanging around.

  153. AJS says:

    As soon as I saw gabby sterp in against a rigt handed pitcher I knew the game was over. Dude can’t hit righties. I would definitely bring him back if they can find a platoon for him other than Jones. I really like Garrett but he is just putrid right now.

  154. Jandy says:

    That’s the ones you gotta watch out for!

  155. Lad9 says:

    I am still working on a comment on violating the Prime Directive that doesn’t get me banned from the blog…. :)

  156. Jandy says:

    ONE play did not lose the game last night…anymore than ONE PLAY loses it any given night. Locke pitched poorly, Mercer/Walker bobbled that play at second and only got one out. Too many hitters left runners on base.

    Not excusing Tabby, but not saying HE lost the game, either.

  157. He had 2 hits last night. Wonder when the last time was Garrett had 2 in a game.

    You’re right though. Putting Tabata in left and Lambo or Jones in right widens center quite a bit for Cutch.

  158. Jandy says:

    Has he been tested recently? I know it doesn’t excuse what he did last year…

  159. Jandy says:

    Work harder, Rad Lad! ;)

  160. Jandy says:

    Poor Cutch.

  161. JohninOshkosh says:

    Precisely why I want the Bucs to win the division. Not interested in seeing a three team dogfight for the last WC spot. Takes a big toll on your staff and prevents you from getting your rotation in order for the playoffs.

    That’s why they got to beat up on saps like Milwaukee.

  162. Milo Hamilton says:

    I was just talking about his fielding. When he didn’t even try to throw home on that short sac fly, he told me what he thinks of his own arm.

  163. Jandy says:

    Yes, I agree…and I was very disappointed last night.

  164. Jandy says:

    I miss Marte!

  165. Nate83 says:

    What….2 for 19. That’s not possible. The guy was on fire. Are you telling me his previous 3 years was more of a clue on how he would play the rest of the way then a 20 games stretch.

  166. AJS says:

    Depends what are we panicing about? 82 wins? Missing the playoffs? Not winning the division?

    They will get 82. They will even still likely make the playoffs. I was talking to a totally objective observer today who thinks as longa s they go better than say 10 wins the rest of the way it will be very hard to blow an 8 game wild card lead.

    I don’t see them being much worse than a .500 club the rest of the way.

    Those are the 2 things I care about. I am far from panicing over either of them.

  167. Jandy says:

    :thwap:

  168. 21sthebest says:

    +1

  169. 21sthebest says:

    +++++++

    Saying this or that play loses a game never made sense to me. 70+ batters, couple of hundred pitches, etc…

  170. AJS says:

    there si just too much pitching for this team to have a repeat performance of last September. Liriano is a better than 50% chance of shutting a team down. AJ is fins as long as he is yanked before he does something stupid. Dare I say Morton has even looked good over hi past several starts. 7-21 is not on the horion.

  171. Milo Hamilton says:

    I think he’s the player to be named, by the way.

  172. War Horse says:

    I hate to be the truth squad who cleans up after others here make mistakes, but we have to stop calling John Buck “a backup catcher,” even though he may be used as one by CH. Buck has been anything but a backup for the Mets this season and throughout his career. This year he has played in 101 games, had 397 plate appearances (368 AB + 22 BB), hit 15 HR and 60 RBI. If that’s a backup catcher, I’m a monkey’s uncle. The Mets’ backup catcher has been Anthony Recker all season. So let’s get it right before it becomes a habit. You, too, DK. Buck is not, as you wrote today, “a workmanlike backup catcher.”

  173. Nate83 says:

    It’s the series of former Pirates coming back to haunt the current team.

  174. JohninOshkosh says:

    Does anyone know (from Twitter, for example) when Dejan is going to be on Olbermann ? I assume he will be on in the first segment like Whitlock and Kornheiser were.

    I saw the first episode and Dejan doesn’t have to do much to beat Whitlock in terms of wardrobe!

    I wish Dejan had been on when Olbermann ripped newspapers. Dejan has always been an eloquent defender of print media while simultaneously channeling the new media effectively. I get that the Daily News reporter needed to be chided but Olbermann’s inclusion of the entire print media in his chastisement was beyond the pale.

    Olbermann hardly broke new ground last night with Kornhiser suggesting that college athletes are exploited and need to be paid.

    I would be more impressed if he laid into ESPN for its pulling out of the PBS Frontline documentary. I guess I’ll rely on Deadspin for that criticism.

  175. Naje says:

    Well, Marte lost a game by dropping a routine fly ball in the 9th…

  176. pattonbb says:

    Nothing really rhymes with Marlon.

    And I think those situations, while not different, were certainly handled differently by the two players. Byrd accepted responsibility and has talked about it, almost to death. Lyin’ Ryan is a piece of $%!@ that still refuses to admit anything wrong happened.

    Are we suppose to Boo every known and sanctioned PED user now? I thought we weren’t supposed to Boo anymore. These rules are so confusing….

  177. pattonbb says:

    Shhh! We don’t mention that anymore.

  178. Bob Hasis says:

    Neither do Tabby

  179. JohninOshkosh says:

    Yes I know they are. That’s why I am sort of coming around to Naje’s way of thinking. Just legalize the stuff.

    I get the Lyin’ Ryan stuff. It’s funny too. But isn’t a cheat a cheat ?

  180. Man o’ War,

    Since Mets brought up Travis D’Arnaud, their best Minor League prospect, obtained from Blue Jays for RA Dickey, John Buck has been designated the “back-up catcher.”

    Mets may still pursue Buck as D’Arnaud’s back-up for next year.

    At the trade, John Buck was the back-up.

  181. War Horse says:

    Here’s an excellent review of the first Dobermann show by the NY Times TV critic, Alessandra Stanley:

    http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/28/arts/television/keith-olbermanns-show-has-its-debut-on-espn2.html?ref=television

  182. Arriba Wilver says:

    +++

  183. Bob Hasis says:

    Without Marte, CF is already widened. We need to shrink it a little – which of course Marte does when he plays, allowing Cutch to lend a little more help toward RF

    I also didn’t say Tabby lost the game with that play – it just didn’t help, did it?

  184. Kevin says:

    so you’re saying Martin is a backup catcher? that would be hard to imagine that our MVP would suddenly be relegated to backup…or are you just saying we now have two starting catchers?

  185. Oshkosh b’Gosh,

    I like Keith Olbermann as a baseball guy.

    I did not like last night. It took him a long time to get anywhere, and no new ground was unearthed. Kornheiser was extraordinarily lame.

    Last night belonged on Current. This show might not last long enough for Dejan to don his tie and sportscoat.

  186. Jandy says:

    Agreed on Locke. And after he skips one, if he can’t cut it, send him for rehab or something, give Cumpton a chance. Locke has that “look” and it’s not good.

  187. 21sthebest says:

    I didn’t think it was short necessarily and I figured he threw the ball where he was told to.

  188. Jandy says:

    No, it sure didn’t Mr. Hasis.

  189. Jandy says:

    :thwap:

  190. 21sthebest says:

    August 10th Lucky.

  191. Thundercrack says:

    Pedro hit it too hard and made it bounce over the fence

  192. Jandy says:

    haha, I was waiting for that.

  193. Closer than I thought. Thanks.

  194. JohninOshkosh says:

    It’s an OK show. I’ll watch it only when Dejan is on, though.

  195. Thundercrack says:

    +1
    That is they way I saw it too Naterosboro.

  196. Hasty Bob,

    I do not understand your comment, unless you were just trying to be flip.

    1/ Tabata was the starting left fielder before Marte
    2/ Lambo can barely play right
    3/ Who else would you suggest Manager of the Year Hurdle start in left instead of Tabata?

  197. pattonbb says:

    I do think a cheat is a cheat. I just don’t understand why PED use is the only form of cheating we’re supposed to be disgusted by. What about a guy who takes a base when the ump thinks he was hit by a pitch, but really wasn’t? Is that cheating? Stealing signs? Trapped balls? Sliding into 2nd or 3rd with spikes up? Framing pitches? Hidden ball trick?

    Where does the line to cross start or stop?

  198. Arriba Wilver says:

    I often agree with you John. (I don’t always agree, even with me). But if Braun had gotten caught last year, served his suspension, admitted he took it, even said it was accidental or whatever, I wouldn’t think of him any differently than Byrd (because of the suspension). What he did AFTER getting lucky with the technicality makes all the difference to me. No comparison.

  199. tomp says:

    I have 1 question pertaining to the PTBNL in the Marlon Byrd/John Buck trade.

    Since it is obvious both teams know who this player is, can the Met’s insist that this player no longer plays in games for the Pirates or any of their affiliates ?.

    Technically, this player is now property of the Met’s, and besides having a spy/scout/doctor in the stands, he can’t really give any instruction to this guy.

    I would say watch the guys on the minor league rosters, especially on the 40, and see who is riding the bench for the remainder of the season.

    I can only imagine the Met’s would not be too happy if the player they plan on acquiring, would get injured, or if it’s a pitcher, suffer an arm injury.

  200. tomp says:

    Maybe he backed out , when he found out what the 1st show topics were going to be.

    Don’t want to ruffle the feathers of the new boss!!.

  201. Arriba Wilver says:

    Tabby’s no Marte, but he did play left his first year up, with few complaints.

  202. JohninOshkosh says:

    Agreed.

    Which means I’m disagreeing with me but agreeing with you who sometimes disagrees with yourself ? :)

  203. Jandy says:

    uhh… yeah!

    you two kill me…lol

  204. JohninOshkosh says:

    Excellent questions. Perhaps, why I enjoyed taking philosophy courses.

    Are there any Kantian Categorical Imperatives in baseball ?

    Is there crying in baseball ?

  205. Bob Hasis says:

    1. Does playing 15 games or so in left under a default mode give him the title LFer?

    2. Were you one of the throng demanding Lambo “get here” without knowing whether he could hit or play defense?

    3. I want to give you more to rail about, but I would have had JHay in there and leave Tabby in right. Oh I know the left-handed batter who cant hit or play defense had to be in there at any cost.

    So were you happy that you had two players out of position instead of one.

    No matter what you say, JHay gives an effort no matter where he plays – Tabby has rightfully earned the name of “loafer”.

    JHay would have had a jump whereas Tabby was very casual going after it.

    As to Mgr. of the Year, sorry Charlie, not this year

  206. War Horse says:

    Groat: Yes, you’re so right. “At the trade, John Buck was the back-up.” So that earns him the published description as a “workmanlike backup catcher” eh? After ten years in the majors and over 1,000 games as a starting catcher, Buck will henceforth be known as “a workmanlike backup catcher” because he was replaced as the starting catcher for the NY Mets 10 days ago (August 17th), when Travis d’Arnaud made his Major League debut. Does a little dexterity with semantics once in a while make you a full-time serious analyst? Methinks not.

  207. Brandie says:

    Ah….a love :thwap:!

  208. War Horse says:

    All I was saying is that John Buck has been a starting catcher all his career and that calling him “a workmanlike backup catcher” was incorrect. I said that CH may use him as a backup, but nevermind. You don’t know how to argue intelligently and I won’t waste my time with you.

  209. Jandy says:

    Question 1 – NO, logic is not allowed ;)

    Question 2 – youbetcha!

  210. Brandie says:

    Or Phil Garner!

  211. Milo Hamilton says:

    I’ll go with mine, thanks.

  212. Jandy says:

    Groat loves attention, so he should love that one ;)

  213. Bob Hasis says:

    Convenient loss of recall. Tabby has been mediocre from the outset of his career here.

    AW whichever way the wind blows is irrelevant, just do not agree with me. It wouldn’t become you.

  214. Karen22 says:

    STOP IT! ;)

    I will admit to having deviated from my agenda this year regarding the Pirates: NO expectations; enjoy the games ONE day at a time; I’ll be happy if they just play consistent, good baseball and break the streak this year.

    I don’t want to panic, so I’m trying (desperately) to recover that mantra. You’re not helping, Mr. Plan!

  215. Karen22 says:

    Or Mr. Lease!

  216. Jandy says:

    OK, I finally read the Wednesday column. I get what Walker said. Really. He’s darned if he does and darned if he doesn’t. But yeah, how about “I’m not happy for the guys who will be out now, but excited to see what Byrd can contribute.”
    Anyone nitpicking this is just looking for a chance to do just that.
    And *I* have blasted Walker for being wussified for the times he’s sat out games for minor injuries.

    I do have one question, tho. In the picture I see Byrd wearing No. 6. Marte currently is wearing No. 6. What is protocol here?

  217. Bob Hasis says:

    Then with all of that experience in left, that shot should have been a can of corn.

    Jhay would have been all over it. I know JHay will never win a Gold Glove, but I know few players who try harder than he, ON EVERY PLAY.

  218. 21sthebest says:

    I’ll go with accuracy.

  219. Arriba Wilver says:

    :-)

  220. 21sthebest says:

    Actually I think that’s a long time ago as far as two hit games go.

  221. Brandie says:

    A Wrestle Off.

    There can only be ONE #6!

  222. 21sthebest says:

    That’s….you know….

  223. Karen22 says:

    ++++

  224. Milo Hamilton says:

    Except you’re wrong.

  225. Jandy says:

    Mud or jello?

  226. Karen22 says:

    Who? Tabby, Jones, or Lambo?

  227. Jandy says:

    BASEBALL! :D

  228. Jandy says:

    Bejezuz! here we go again!

  229. Karen22 says:

    Poor Cutch is right…His shoulders have to be sagging under all this weight! And he scorched every ball last night – could have had a four-hit night like Petey.

  230. Karen22 says:

    Badly!

  231. Bizrow says:

    I think Marte could give the number to Byrd if he wants, otherwise its Marte’s

  232. Jandy says:

    Better dimes than quarters, they won’t hurt as much ;)

  233. Karen22 says:

    How about Pie-a la-Mode?? I’d rather see him in left!

  234. Bizrow says:

    A PTBML usually comes from a list of players, Mets will choose from the agreed to list later on.

    Usually, that is,

  235. Jandy says:

    Thanks, Biz!

  236. Jandy says:

    Chocolate?

  237. Karen22 says:

    STFU, Milo! ;)

  238. Jandy says:

    BOOM!

  239. Arriba Wilver says:

    Are you in England, War Horse, or is that a different guy?

  240. Brandie says:

    It’s Player To Be Named Later, Not Players…

  241. 21sthebest says:

    Nope.

  242. Brandie says:

    PUT IT ON A T-SHIRT, RARIN’ KAREN! :-)

  243. Brandie says:

    And Butterscotch!

  244. Brandie says:

    Does the M in PTBML stand for Maimed?

  245. Brandie says:

    Or Possibly Marginalized?

  246. Brandie says:

    That means discussing football on a baseball thread.

  247. Dom says:

    I can’t imagine it would be anyone good.

  248. Brandie says:

    Or the ghost of Pie Traynor.

  249. Bizrow says:

    stupid typos ;-)

  250. War Horse says:

    –The Pirates’ won-lost record from April to the end of June was 51-30.
    –In the last two months, July & August, it is 25-25, and in the last 2 1/2 weeks it’s 6-11.
    –The team’s hitting in tight ball games has been atrocious, especially with RISP. That we all know. But the hitting as measured by BA has improved marginally in the past two months. If you look at the stats month by month, the team BA has gone from .245 to .251. Overall run production has been consistently poor. But it was OK earlier in the season because our pitching was the best in the majors.
    –Now, though, the won-loss record is going downhill fast because the quality of the pitching is in decline.
    –From July to August, the collective ERA of all Pittsburgh pitchers has gone from 2.77 to 4.05.
    –The number of runs given up has balooned from 81 to 107 (and still counting in August).
    –Opponents’ BA has gone from .228 (similar to April-July) to .279.
    –And, finally, WHIP has gone from 1.17 to 1.42. Those last two stats are both the worst in the NL for the month of August, to date.
    –If this trend continues, the decline in the W-L record will follow.
    –It’s time to take a closer, more critical look at what’s happening to cause these poor performances by the pitching staff.

  251. Brandie says:

    No Problem, Strictly Biz.

  252. Bob Hasis says:

    Groat had answers or options, he just likes “funnin’ with me.

    I like playing his game.

    Yes Karen, you are right, a very viable option, AND a left-handed batter too, which was the only reason Lame-bo was in there

  253. pattonbb says:

    Immanuel Kant references? I don’t think even Dennis MIller could tie baseball and Kant together. Well done!

  254. Naje says:

    How about the following for the decline of the pitching staff:

    –they’re dominance as a collective group was based on the several (at least six) pitchers pitching way beyond career norms…probably more than just six.

    –those pitchers, specifically Locke, Morris, Wilson, Cole, Burnett and now Liriano, have regressed either quite a bit or just enough to notice.

    –the bullpen has had to eat a lot of innings since the ASB and without Grilli, everyone in the ‘pen has been asked to step forward and take on bigger, higher leverage situations.

    –the team has used 26 pitchers this year… injuries, setbacks, flameouts, etc… that’s a LOT of pitchers for a team that is 21 games over .500.

    –They’re tired… worn down from dealing with an anemic offense every game. Much of that fatigue goes to the extreme slumps of Alvarez, the absolute awful at bats Jones has had in the past six weeks (and for most of the season), the lack of hitting from anyone hitting behind Alvarez (Jones, Martin, Snider, Sanchez, Lambo, etc) and an awful bad habit of striking out as well as not hitting worth a darn with runners in scoring position.

    That just about takes care of the dropoff in the pitching staff, doesn’t it?

  255. AJS says:

    Funny just a couple weeks ago people were ready to string him up for dropping a single fly ball and having the audacity to cracka grin.

  256. JohninOshkosh says:

    Groat:

    16 years old. Deserted country road, Iowa. Jenny X (last name withheld). My father’s Chevy Citation. She did not wave me into third.

  257. AJS says:

    Tabby was the every day left fielder for almost 2 seasons before they moved him to right to”take advantage of his arm”

  258. 21sthebest says:

    “In the last two months, July & August, it is 25-25″

    I wonder if anyone knows what the North American record is for consecutive sub .500′s in July and August.

  259. Jandy says:

    Thank you Osh Kosh, I was waiting for this to come up! LOL

    Jenny missed out ;)

  260. AJS says:

    NH said last night it would be an “ouch” and not a “who”

    have no idea what that means really.

  261. AJS says:

    I believe in some cases when a guy comes in if he wants a particular nuimber he can ask the guy wearing it. Sometimes if they want it bad enough they will ven “buy” it from them with an expensive dinner, rolex watch, etc. Didn’t AJ put someones kid through college or something last spring? Or was that not AJ?

  262. AJS says:

    So rememebr all the conversation at the begining of the year about the over use of the bull pen? So uh ya.

  263. Nate83 says:

    What Biz is saying is usually the way it is done. The Mets may actually want those players to play because they may be scouting them currently to decide which player to pick.

  264. Bizrow says:

    Byrd is only here thru the end of the season, so if Marte “sold” No. 6 to him, he could get it right back in ST if he wants it

  265. Brendan says:

    I’d agree that if I would have preferred to see this precise trade (Herrera + a PTBNL for Byrd and Buck) made a month ago. It seems pretty likely this iteration of the trade wasn’t available a month ago.

    Given Byrd’s production this season, the small amount of money he was owed, and the fact he comes off the books after the season I’d have to think he was an attractive option for quite a few teams, not just the Pirates. That he wasn’t traded, in combination with Sandy Alderson’s quote, in which he said it would take an overwhelming return for the Mets to move him, I have to think the asking price was much higher pre July 31. Also it seemed like the Mets wanted to remain as competitive as possible for the remainder of the season, so as to not lose their fans, etc. I wonder if the lose of Matt Harvey changed there thinking at all?

    In any case if the Pirates had given up more in return I may have liked the trade less. Dilson Herrara is a legimate prospect, albeit it not an elite one. I hate to lose him, but it’s what had to be done. Since we don’t now what it would have taken to get these guys a month earlier it’s impossible to specualte.

    Ultimately they have them now. The Pirates are still 1 and a half games out of first with quite a few games left against St. Louis. Might they be in first with more of a cushion had they acted sooner? Possibly. But barring a tremendous collapse they’ll at worst be the second wild card and in the playoffs with Byrd on the squad and Marte and Grilli back in the fold.

    I’d prefer they were able to avoid the one game playoff because of course anything can happen in one game. Had they slid out of a playoff spot entirely over the last month I’d probably be frustrated they’d not acted sooner. But they’ve managed to more or less hold serve. I feel like reasonably optimistic about this lineup/staff going into a post-season series:

    Marte
    Walker
    Cutch
    Alvarez
    Byrd
    Martin
    Jones/Sanchez
    Mercer/Barmes

    Liriano, Burnett, Morton, and possibly Cole

    I’ve not been a huge advocate of trading for Justin Morneau as he’s not been significantly better than Garrett Jones over the course of the entire season. But given the way Jones has played of late it seems like more of a pressing need.

  266. Lad9 says:

    The way I read that, when the player gets named, the Pirate fans will not be saying “who”, we will be saying “ouch”. In other words, it is not a Rikhu Singh type player, more a Barrett Barnes maybe? Just guessing, but I did guess on this blog that Herrera would be the one to go. Even a blind squirrel …….

  267. Oshkosh b’Gosh,

    Jenny’s loss is Mrs. Oshkosh’s gain.

    No room for 3rd base in a Citation!

    But I’ll bet Mrs. Oshkosh b’Gosh kept thinking as she waved you on, “Where did this inexperienced Iowa boy come from? I thought he would be worth more than 82 wins.”

  268. JD says:

    Good one Nate

  269. Man o’ War,

    As a 33 year old catcher who has batting numbers since May 1——7 HR and around a .200 batting average——similar to Rod Barajas last season,
    and who had been replaced as starter on his team by a raw rookie . . . . . I would think Dejan’s description of Buck as “a workmanlike backup catcher” is just about right on the nose.

    I’m not sure what you were so upset with Dejan about.

    If he beats out Russell Martin and his .240 average, I’ll call Buck “starter.”

  270. Baywatch says:

    Thank you, War Horse … I’m thoroughly depressed now. As long as we haven’t collapsed. That’s not what we’ve done, is it? But as I alluded to above earlier, I think I’d rather us be good or bad. Hate the inbetween stuff!

  271. A.J. “bought” his number from Daniel McCutchen.

    Daniel used the money to buy PEDs.

  272. Mike A. says:

    After being flummoxed by Ryan Vogelsong in SF…

  273. theplanisworking says:

    Milo, you are correct.
    On TV, it didnt even appear he was setting up for a throw home. Maybe the coaches told him to throw to second, but I doubt it.

    Good call.

  274. theplanisworking says:

    +++++++++

  275. If trying hard was the deciding factor in baseball, McKenry would bat .400!

    JHay would still be turning both directions looking for the ball. He CANNOT play outfield any better than a pitcher shagging flies.

    Tabata just had the ball go off his glove. Tough break. Just like Mercer had the ball fall out of his glove on the easy doubleplay, and Gaby didn’t quite reach that foul pop. No one gets every ball.

  276. Lad9 says:

    I was really close to this, essentially right behind Lambo. I think he took a bad route to the ball because it carried further than he thought it would. Hecouild not line himself up to run up on the ball, do a crow hop, and get a strong throw home since he was already too shallow for that. So he chose to go to second. Even if he did everything right and threw home, his chances of getting the runner were very small, but I was suprised from where I sat that we didn’t try. Not a great play, and I bet he would tell you that himself.

  277. 21sthebest says:

    Coaches wouldn’t be telling him where to throw. Fielders would be.

  278. Kevin says:

    Wasn’t even trying to argue, sorry if it came off that way… was just trying to understand what point you were making. Thanks anyway for clearing it up.

  279. 21sthebest says:

    Lad, it looks like he’s behind the ball to me and took steps forward to catch it. I don’t think he was lined up directly towards home though which is why I thought he was maybe hearing “2″ being yelled.

    If the defense isn’t communicating, they’re not doing their job, IMO.

  280. 21sthebest says:

    Apparently, Grilli to rejoin the team September 1 pending the outcome of today’s sim game.

  281. Jandy says:

    That would be sweeeeettt!!!!!

  282. Arriba Wilver says:

    He sounded very positive on that Mission October show. Said his forearm strain was a forearm strain. Teke kept insisting the night he was hurt that it didn’t look to him like it was an elbow problem. Hope they’re both right. We could use him.

  283. theplanisworking says:

    Anyone with word on Juan D. and his visit to Dr. Julie Andrews? Oops…. James.

    Any word on Locke going to DL? He has lost MPH off his pitches recently………..

  284. Bizrow says:

    Wandy is back in Pittsburgh, I think I heard NH say they are analyzing the test results.

  285. Lad9 says:

    He got in too far too quick 21 – no doubt in my mind – and just mis-timed it. And I thought then he lined himself up towards second. Cutch may have told him 2 – he would have been the only one he could have heard (maybe Neil but I doubt it) but I can’t confirm that. It looked real awkward too from my viewpoint – like there was indecision. At any rate, I seriously doubt he gets Betancourt at home.

  286. Lad9 says:

    +39!!

  287. theplanisworking says:

    Thanks Biz.

    I just heard all the fanfare about going to see Andrews, then the blcak hole of silence crept in………..

    BTW, Go like ’60.

  288. 21sthebest says:

    I don’t think he had a shot either Lad, however, it looks to me that he did get behind the ball and was taking steps forward as he caught it.

    Walker was headed to first and had his back to the play. Lambo would be able to hear Barmes and Martin.

  289. theplanisworking says:

    Should say “black”.

    Damn Jandy typos………

  290. Jandy says:

    You called? ;)

  291. Nate83 says:

    He actually started a college fund for Daniel McCutchen’s child.

  292. Arriba Wilver says:

    Biz— 6:35. See you there.

  293. theplanisworking says:

    Hiya, Nun Sense.

    just popping quickly to avoid crap on here.
    Hope your workday is going fast.
    And, hope to see you in the game thread tonight.

  294. Arriba Wilver says:

    Getting moderated.

  295. Baywatch says:

    LOL! Sorta?

  296. Any of you Tweet Freaks hear who was sent down to add Byrd and Buck to 25-man?

    I’m guessing Tony Sanchez and Lambo, but I guess it could be Cherry Pie.

    Probably send Sanchez to Indy to catch in playoffs; Lambo to Altoona to get him back to Pittsburgh sooner, since no playoffs there.

  297. Baywatch says:

    PlanIs, I called Dr. Andrews office and asked about Wandy. There was this pause, then a little music followed by …. THE HILLS ARE ALIVE, WITH THE SOUND OF MUSIC! Dr. Julie Andrews! LOL!

  298. Nor Cal Stlrfanrtc (Ryan) says:

    Great column DK.

    As you mentioned in the game thread NW’s reaction was overblown. He’s right, he needs to support his teammates. That’s what leaders do.

    This is a great deal for the Pirates. Byrd is an automatic upgrade and Buck is an upgrade to the back up position. I like what Tony Sanchez brings to the future, but the Pirates should not have been relying on him for a playoff run. Too much added pressure on the guy. He has enough of that. This run will be a good learning experience for Tony. 2 proven veteran catchers to learn from.

    Good move. Now its up to the players to perform up to their expectations.

    Justin Morneau??

  299. theplanisworking says:

    Hahahahaha!

  300. Nor Cal Stlrfanrtc (Ryan) says:

    He never had much velocity to begin with, I dont perceive it being caused by injury.

  301. Nor Cal Stlrfanrtc (Ryan) says:

    He was with the team on the road trip as well..

  302. Jandy says:

    Chances are I’ll at least be on for a bit, like last night. Hope I catch you, took, Planimal :)
    Time flies so fast at work I don’t know where it goes!

  303. Jandy says:

    ZING!

  304. Jandy says:

    I was under the impression Locke made his living by getting batters to hit ground out balls.

    He’s lost his control.

  305. Jandy says:

    How the heck did this get here? It was to go under the Jeff Locke comments…sheeesh. I’ll repost it.

  306. Jandy says:

    I was under the impression Locke made his living by getting batters to hit ground out balls.

    He’s lost his control.

  307. theplanisworking says:

    Agreed.

    But he has lost about 5 MPH off his pitches, especially after only a few innings work.
    Just odd, thats all.

  308. Jandy says:

    yeah he was definitely on a roll. Cutch MVP!

  309. Jandy says:

    Not me, AJS, I defended him.

  310. WVStarship says:

    Darlin’ rhymes with Marlon.

  311. Jandy says:

    seriously? Now that’s classy.

  312. Jandy says:

    You’re a bad, bad boy, AW :P

  313. Jandy says:

    Yes it is odd. He has “the look” too. He needs help. Get it for him…FAST.

  314. Jandy says:

    so does Snarlin’

  315. JohninOshkosh says:

    Watching a little bit of the Cubs/Dodgers.

    Dale Svuem ejected in first inning for arguing about a check swing.

    Frustrated, much ?

    At least we get to debate about how the Pirates can maintain a playoff position. Cubs fan have a first base man signed to a long extension that looks mediocre. Their star shortstop, once a can’t miss, has batted in the eighth spot recently. They have Edwin Freakin’ Jackson signed to a long, expensive contract. They can’t come to an agreement on an extension for their best pitcher. Lots of empty seats at their ballpark attraction.

    Oh, and they haven’t even won so much as a lousy pennant in 58 years.

  316. AJS says:

    That’s what I thought. That was really classy.

  317. I knew that too,
    but it’s much funnier to say that Daniel used it to buy PEDs, since he got suspended for 50 games this year.

  318. JohninOshkosh says:

    *68

  319. theplanisworking says:

    What did you think of the Mission : October show, AW?

  320. 21sthebest says:

    Interesting, his fastball velocity averaged 91.2 on 8/22. Yesterday’s isn’t posted yet. And that 91.2 was his highest since 7/26 (91.8 – highest of the year). His fastball is averaging 90.2 for the year.

  321. I’d take their 1st baseman Rizzo . . . .

    . . . . but Starlin Castro may not be the best shortstop on their team come September,
    and his contract goes on until the cows come home.

  322. 21sthebest says:

    Harrison
    Mercer
    Cutch
    Byrd
    Pedro
    Gabby
    Martin
    Tabs
    Chuck

    Sanchez sent down. Haven’t seen the other move yet.

  323. 21sthebest says:

    Sanchez will be back 9/1.

  324. Bizrow says:

    ok, AW, got it

  325. Jandy says:

    OO0= OO0= OO0= OO0= OO0= OO0= OO0= OO0= OO0=
    Game thread is up ~~~~~~~~~~>

  326. War Horse says:

    Kevin, My apologies for sounding off so sharply. Of course Buck will be backup for Martin this season. I didn’t make my main point clearly enough. I wasn’t upset with DK. I am one of his admirers. I was merely correcting what I thought was an off-hand description, using the past tense, as if to indicate that Buck had been a backup catcher in the past, which he clearly was not. Buck is a first rate catcher who has been a starter for 10 years and 1,000 games. We are fortunate to have both Martin and Buck and their experience behind the plate for the final month of the season.

  327. Kevin says:

    FREE MORNEAU!?

  328. Kevin says:

    Thank ye Jandilicious!

  329. War Horse says:

    Yes, Naje, it does. Excellent analysis. Just add to that the fact that Locke may have spent a little too much time and tried too hard to be A.J.’s protege. He was doing brilliantly on his own for a while.

  330. Nor Cal Stlrfanrtc (Ryan) says:

    90.2 on the fastball isn’t high velocity in the MLB. Maybe for us, but not for those guys.

 
Other blogs
Sports: Rob Rossi | Steel Mill | Chipped Ice | Bucco Blog | iPreps | Pitt Locker Room | Penn State Sports | Trailing Off
News: This Just In | Trib List | ICycle  


» Top TribLIVE.com Sports
» Top TribLIVE.com News
» Top TribLIVE.com Breaking News